Medium Range Forecast: Restoring Fiscal Balance

 

2001-02 Outturn

 

63.     Let me now elaborate on the Government's plan to solve the deficit problem in the medium term.  First, I forecast a consolidated deficit of $65.6 billion for 2001-02 (equivalent to 5.2% of GDP), far larger than the original estimate of $3 billion.  This is due mainly to revenue from land premiums and investment income from our fiscal reserves falling far short of our original forecasts.  Furthermore, the secondary offering of Mass Transit Railway shares originally planned for this financial year has been postponed to the next because of changes in investment market conditions.  I estimate the fiscal reserves to be $369.8 billion by 31 March this year, roughly equivalent to 19 months of government expenditure.

 

Restoring Fiscal Balance Step by Step

 

64.   Earlier, I set three targets for our public finances in 2006-07 -
  • first, restore balance in the Consolidated Account;

  • second, attain a balanced Operating Account; and

  • third, reduce public expenditure to 20% of GDP or below.

I aim to achieve these targets step by step through reducing the growth of government expenditure and modestly raising revenue.  I believe this is a practical strategy commensurate with our economic condition.

 

Controlling Expenditure Growth in Real Terms

 

65.     Having regard to the current state of our economy, I have decided to allow government expenditure in 2002-03 to grow by 2% in real terms over the original estimate for 2001-02, or 7.7% over the revised estimate, higher than the forecast economic growth of 1% in real terms for 2002.

 

66.     From 2003-04 to 2006-07, I will reduce the real growth in government expenditure to an average of 1.5% each year, lower than the forecast economic growth rate.  I believe Hong Kong's economy should have picked up by then and such a reduction will be necessary to restore fiscal balance in the medium term.

 

Civil Service Pay

 

67.     I have mentioned earlier that it is necessary to control the growth of government expenditure in money terms.  Personnel-related expenses account for 70% of government operating expenditure.  Given our serious fiscal position, I have assumed in the Medium Range Forecast, for financial planning purposes, that civil service pay will be cut by 4.75% and the salary-related portions of subventions to the various organisations will also be reduced by the same rate.  This assumed 4.75% pay cut has taken into account the respective cumulative pay rises for civil servants of different ranks since July 1997.

 

68.     Under the existing mechanism, the Government will consider, among other things, the results of the private sector pay trend survey and its own budgetary position before deciding on an annual civil service pay adjustment.  We will continue to adopt this mechanism and make a final decision after the outcome of this year's survey is known in May.  Any decision on a civil service pay cut needs to go through the legislative process before it can be implemented.  Assuming that the pay cut takes effect from 1 October this year and that the level of reduction is 4.75%, the Government will achieve savings of about $3 billion in 2002-03 and about $6 billion in a full year.

 

69.     Last month, I met with representatives of the civil service central consultative councils and a number of civil service staff unions.  I appreciate their position.  I believe many colleagues in the civil service and the subvented organisations understand that we are facing a serious fiscal situation and that persistent fiscal deficits will adversely affect Hong Kong as a whole.  In fact, many colleagues told me that they were willing to stand by the rest of the community in this time of difficulty and share the burden.

 

 

Doing More with Less

 

70.     In addition, we will stringently contain the growth of the civil service in all ranks.  Last year, the Government proposed to reduce the civil service establishment to around 181 000.  Thanks to the efforts of all departments and grades, we will achieve this target as scheduled in 2002-03.

 

71.     We will also review the demand for services and our priorities for the deployment of resources.  Departments will streamline procedures, simplify structures and economise on manpower in order to release resources to meet additional needs.  Furthermore, we will make use of market forces and strengthen our co-operation with the private sector to provide better and more efficient services to the public through various means.

 

 

Controlling Expenditure Growth in Money Terms

 

72.     Assuming that civil service pay is cut from 1 October this year, government expenditure in 2002-03 will increase in money terms by 0.6% over the original estimate, or 6.2% over the revised estimate, for 2001-02.  Average annual growth of government expenditure from 2003-04 to 2006-07 will be 1% in money terms.  With the foregoing measures for controlling expenditure, I am confident that public expenditure will fall to 20% of GDP in 2006-07.

 


 

Chart 6

Public/Government expenditure as a percentage of GDP

Public/Government expenditure as a percentage of GDP